Lot and his Daughters

Circle of: Joachim Patinir (in circa 1520)

Ask anything

Stéphanie Schwill-Egli asked

May I kindly ask how this painting is related to the Louvre composition, which was catalogued as Lucas van Leyden https://collections.louvre.fr/ark:/53355/cl010061568
And why you catalogue your version as after Patinir. Do we know today who is the inventor of the composition?
Thank you in advance for your insights
Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen answered

Dear Stéphanie, thank you for your question. I have asked our curator of old art and he says that from the 6 known versions of this composition, the one in the Louvre is considered to be the original one. The painting which is kept in our museum - 2456 (OK) - is directly based on the Louvre painting, the other 4 are based on the Boijmans painting. The Louvre painting was originally considered to be a work by Lucas van Leyden – why is not very clear, but probably because of some vague reminiscences with van Leyden's graphical work. The way the painting is executed, however, directs to an origin in Antwerp. Some authors, therefor, suggested Patinir as the artist, especially because of the landscape. There are, however, many deviations from the rest of Patinir's oeuvre and that is why we now consider the painting to be a work by an anonymous follower of Patinir. I hope this is helpful. Kind regards, Els

Thank you. Your question has been submitted.

Unfortunately something has gone wrong while sending your question. Please try again.

TMSFoto/OK/2456 (OK)_XRF_STITCH_RKG2020_06-11.jpg

Request high-res image

More information

Specifications

Title	Lot and his Daughters
Material and technique	Oil on panel
Object type	Painting > Painting > Two-dimensional object > Art object
Location	This object is in storage

Dimensions	Width 45 cm Height 32,5 cm
Artists	Circle of: Joachim Patinir Previously attributed: Lucas van Leyden
Accession number	2456 (OK)
Credits	Acquired with the collection of D.G. van Beuningen, 1958
Department	Old Masters
Acquisition date	1958
Creation date	in circa 1520
Collector	Collector / D.G. van Beuningen
Internal exhibitions	Van Eyck tot Bruegel (1994) BABEL - Oude meesters terug uit Japan / Old Masters Back from Japan (2018)
External exhibitions	Les fables du paysage flamand au XVI siècle, du fantastique au merveilleux (2012) Collection of Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen – Bruegel’s ‘The Tower of Babel’ and Great 16th Century Masters (2017) Boijmans bij de Buren: REMIX ROTTERDAM, Boijmans x Wereldmuseum (2021)
Research	Show research Alma
Material	Panel > Worked wood > Wood > Vegetable material > Organic material > Material > Material and technique Oil > Paint > Artist's material > Material > Material and technique
Object	Painting > Painting > Two-dimensional object > Art object
Place of manufacture	Antwerp > Belgium > Western Europe > Europe
Geographical origin	Northern Netherlands > The Netherlands > Western Europe > Europe

Do you have corrections or additional information about this work? Please, send us a message

Show research Alma

Show catalogue entry Hide catalogue entry

All about the artist

Joachim Patinir

Dinant circa 1475/1480 - Antwerpen 1524

Virtually nothing is known about the life of Joachim Patinir, or Patenier. He appears for the first time in 1515 in the books of the St Luke guild, which he...

Bekijk het volledige profiel